Citrus County, Florida Skylight Contractor Guide
Menu

Skylight repair or replacement: which does yours need?

Many leaking skylights can be fixed without removing the unit. Others have reached the point where repairs keep failing. Knowing which situation you are in helps you compare quotes properly.

Repair is often reasonable when:

  • The glass or dome is intact and the unit is fairly young.
  • The leak traces to flashing, sealant or a loose fastener.
  • The curb and decking around it are dry and solid.

Replacement tends to make more sense when:

  • The dome is yellowed, cracked or brittle from years of Florida sun.
  • Glass has fogged between the panes, meaning the seal has failed.
  • The curb or framing is soft or rotted.
  • You have patched the same skylight more than once.
  • You want better glazing, a solar-powered opening unit or a storm-rated model.

If you are also due for a new roof, replacing the skylight at the same time is common, since the flashing has to be tied into the new roofing anyway. Ask any contractor to explain why they recommend one path over the other, and get the warranty terms for both in writing.

What it costs

Repair is generally the smaller job, and replacement costs more because it involves a new unit, removal of the old one, new flashing and possible curb or interior finish work. The unit size, glazing type, roof material, ceiling shaft height and any rot found once the old unit comes out drive the price. Ask for itemized quotes for both options.

Top 3 by our score

Ranked from our published scoring of public Google reviews for skylight replacement.

  1. 1. Raymond Frankart Roofing
    4.9★ · 150 reviews
    91
  2. 2. Aluminum Structure LLC
    4.8★ · 87 reviews
    87
  3. 3. Cedar Cove Roofing LLC
    4.9★ · 258 reviews
    90

Browse all providers

FAQ

How do I know if my skylight can be repaired?
A contractor should inspect the flashing, curb, glazing and ceiling for moisture. If the problem is limited to sealant or flashing, repair is often possible. Providers vary in how they assess this, so ask what the inspection covers.
Should I replace the skylight when I replace my roof?
Often it is worth discussing. Flashing is tied into the roofing, so doing both together can avoid opening the roof twice. Ask your roofer and skylight contractor how they would coordinate.
Do replacements need a permit?
Permit rules vary by jurisdiction and job. Check with Citrus County Building Division or your city's building department, and ask the contractor whether they handle permitting.